7 Mistakes I See With the House in a Divorce (From an Appraiser)
I’m Jason Clow, a State Certified Residential Appraiser in Phoenix. I’ve appraised a lot of homes for divorces across Maricopa County, and I’ve noticed the same mistakes come up again and again. None of them are about the law. Your attorney or mediator handles that. They’re about the house and the number everyone ends up arguing over.
I’ve also been through a divorce myself. I know what it feels like when the house turns into the hardest part of the conversation, and how quickly a number can become a fight. That experience is a big reason I take one thing so seriously in these assignments: I don’t work for either spouse. My job is an honest, supported value that both of you can work from.
Here are the seven I’d warn you about first.
1. Settling on an online estimate
I understand the appeal. It’s free, it’s instant, and it feels neutral because neither of you picked it. But an online estimate never walked through the house. It doesn’t know about the new roof, the cracked slab or the kitchen that was redone last year, and it can be off by tens of thousands of dollars in either direction.
In a buyout, that error goes straight into one spouse’s pocket and out of the other’s. If the house is the biggest thing you own together, it deserves a value that someone can explain and defend. More on that: appraisal vs. CMA vs. Zestimate.
2. Each spouse hiring their own appraiser without talking first
When each side orders its own appraisal, you usually get two different numbers. Then you argue about which one is right, and sometimes end up paying for a third. That costs time, money and goodwill you may need for everything else.
Many spouses agree on one neutral appraiser instead, and name both spouses and both attorneys as users of the report. That way everyone gets the same report at the same time. Ask your attorney or mediator whether that works in your case.
3. Not agreeing on the value date
“What’s the house worth?” always has a second question hiding in it: worth as of when? Today? The date you separated? The date someone filed? In a market that moves, those can be very different numbers.
Your attorneys decide which date applies. Settle it before you order, because the appraiser needs it to start. I can appraise as of today, as of a past date, or both. More on that: divorce appraisal dates.
4. Trying to steer the appraiser
This one I see more than you’d think. One spouse sends a list of reasons the house is worth more, or less. Someone mentions the number they “need.” Someone follows me room to room pointing out every flaw.
I understand why. A lot is riding on it. But an appraiser is required to be independent, and I can’t be pushed toward a number by either side. Facts are welcome: a list of updates with dates, a repair estimate, a permit. Pressure doesn’t change the report. It only makes a hard day harder.
5. Changing the house right before the appraisal
Some owners rush to paint and fix everything. Others stop taking care of the place because they’re leaving. Either way, the house on inspection day may not match the house on the date your attorneys chose.
Don’t hide changes. Tell the appraiser what changed and when, and share photos from before if you have them. That’s how a report can describe the home as it was on the right date.
6. Assuming the divorce appraisal works for the refinance
If one spouse keeps the house and refinances to pay the other out, the lender usually orders its own appraisal through its own process. The divorce appraisal is for the divorce: the buyout, the settlement or the sale decision. Ask your lender early so the refinance timeline doesn’t surprise you.
7. Waiting until the week before mediation
The appraisal often ends up being the one thing everyone is waiting on. Most of my reports are delivered within 2 to 3 business days after the inspection, but the inspection still has to be scheduled with whoever has access to the house. If you have a mediation or court date, order early and tell the appraiser the date.
When the other spouse won’t cooperate
It happens. If one spouse won’t allow access, an appraisal can often still be completed in a different way. Talk to your attorney first, then tell me what’s going on when you start the request.
Get a value both sides can work with
West Valley Appraisal Services prepares neutral divorce residential real estate appraisals for spouses, attorneys and mediators throughout Phoenix and Maricopa County, Arizona, as of today or a past date.
See how divorce appraisals work, read who keeps the house in an Arizona divorce, or call or text (602) 717-8450.
Written by Jason Clow, State Certified Residential Appraiser #21559. This article is general information, not legal or tax advice. Your attorney decides how the home is handled in your case.
Related service: Divorce
Need a residential real estate appraisal?
West Valley Appraisal Services provides residential real estate appraisals throughout Phoenix / Maricopa County, Arizona.